Effects of Circuit Class Training Versus Individual, Task Specific Training on Upper Extremity Function in Chronic Stroke Patients
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background: Stroke is a leading contributor to disability globally, emphasizing the need for effective rehabilitation techniques. Circuit class training (CCT) and individual, task-specific training (ITST) have emerged as potential approaches for enhancing upper extremity function in stroke survivors. Comparative analyses of their efficacy, especially among chronic stroke patients, are scant.
Objective: This study aimed to evaluate and compare the impacts of CCT and ITST on upper extremity spasticity, motor function, and quality of life in individuals with chronic stroke.
Methods: In a randomized controlled trial, 36 chronic stroke patients were allocated to either CCT or ITST groups. Participants were aged 45-70 years, had experienced a single stroke episode, and were at least 6 months post-stroke, with specific inclusion criteria regarding spasticity and motor function levels. The interventions were delivered for 1.5 hours daily, five days a week, over eight weeks. Outcomes were measured using the Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS) for spasticity, Functional Independence Measure for Upper Extremity (FMA-UE) for motor function, and Stroke-Specific Quality of Life (SS-QOL) scale for quality of life, analyzed using SPSS version 25.
Results: Post-intervention, both CCT and ITST participants exhibited significant improvements in their outcomes. MAS scores showed a reduction in spasticity, with average improvements not significantly differing between the groups. FMA-UE scores increased by an average of 10 points in both groups, indicating enhanced motor function without a significant difference between the groups (p > 0.05). SS-QOL scores improved by an average of 20 points in each group, reflecting better quality of life, with no significant intergroup difference observed.
Conclusion: The study concludes that CCT and ITST are equally effective in ameliorating upper extremity spasticity, motor function, and quality of life among chronic stroke patients. The selection between CCT and ITST can thus be personalized based on patient preferences, available resources, and logistical considerations, maintaining rehabilitation efficacy.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
References
Adeagbo CA, Olawale OA, Gbiri CAO. Transcranial direct current stimulation and repetitive functional task-oriented programme for upper limb functional rehabilitation in stroke survivors. Physical Therapy Reviews. 2021;26(6):420-7.
Alsubiheen AM, Choi W, Yu W, Lee H. The effect of task-oriented activities training on upper-limb function, daily activities, and quality of life in chronic stroke patients: A randomized controlled trial. International journal of environmental research and public health. 2022;19(21):14125.
Alwhaibi RM, Mahmoud NF, Zakaria HM, Badawy WM, Elzanaty MY, Ragab WM, et al. A comparative study on the effect of task specific training on right versus left chronic stroke patients. International journal of environmental research and public health. 2020;17(21):7950.
Anandan D, PK TN, Arun B, Priya V. Effect of task specific training with proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation on stroke survivors. Biomedicine. 2020;40(3):363-6.
Bastola P, Singh P, Pinto D. A comparison of the effect of resistance training on upper extremity motor function, motor recovery, and quality of life in sub-acute stroke participants. Medical Journal of Dr DY Patil University. 2021;14(2):219-25.
Bovonsunthonchai S, Aung N, Hiengkaew V, Tretriluxana J. A randomized controlled trial of motor imagery combined with structured progressive circuit class therapy on gait in stroke survivors. Scientific Reports. 2020;10(1):6945.
da Silva ESM, Ocamoto GN, Santos-Maia GLd, de Fatima Carreira Moreira Padovez R, Trevisan C, de Noronha MA, et al. The effect of priming on outcomes of task-oriented training for the upper extremity in chronic stroke: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Neurorehabilitation and Neural Repair. 2020;34(6):479-504.
Deshpande S, Mohapatra S, Girish N. Influence of task-oriented circuit training on upper limb function among rural community-dwelling survivors of stroke. International Journal of Therapy And Rehabilitation. 2020;27(8):1-8.
Doğan M, Ayvat E, Kılınç M. Telerehabilitation versus virtual reality supported task-oriented circuit therapy on upper limbs and trunk functions in patients with multiple sclerosis: A randomized controlled study. Multiple Sclerosis and Related Disorders. 2023;71:104558.
Donnellan-Fernandez K, Ioakim A, Hordacre B. Revisiting dose and intensity of training: Opportunities to enhance recovery following stroke. Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular Diseases. 2022;31(11):106789.
Dorsch S, Carling C, Cao Z, Fanayan E, Graham PL, McCluskey A, et al. Bobath therapy is inferior to task-specific training and not superior to other interventions in improving arm activity and arm strength outcomes after stroke: a systematic review. Journal of physiotherapy. 2023;69(1):15-22.
Eldemir S, Guclu-Gunduz A, Eldemir K, Saygili F, Yilmaz R, Akbostancı MC. The effect of task-oriented circuit training-based telerehabilitation on upper extremity motor functions in patients with Parkinson's disease: A randomized controlled trial. Parkinsonism & Related Disorders. 2023;109:105334.
Friel KM, Ferre CL, Brandao M, Kuo H-C, Chin K, Hung Y-C, et al. Improvements in upper extremity function following intensive training are independent of corticospinal tract organization in children with unilateral spastic cerebral palsy: a clinical randomized trial. Frontiers in Neurology. 2021;12:660780.
Gnanaprakasam A, Karthikbabu S, Ravishankar N, Solomon JM. Effect of task-based bilateral arm training on upper limb recovery after stroke: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Stroke and Cerebrovascular Diseases. 2023;32(7):107131.
Hsu H-Y, Kuan T-S, Tsai C-L, Wu P-T, Kuo Y-L, Su F-C, et al. Effect of a novel perturbation-based pinch task training on sensorimotor performance of upper extremity for patients with chronic stroke: A pilot randomized controlled trial. Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. 2021;102(5):811-8.
Ibrahim R, Lawal IU, Joseph C. Intensity of Task-Specific Training for Functional Ability Post-stroke: Protocol for a Systematic Review. 2021.
Johar MN, Nordin NAM, Yusoff YAM. Effects of Game-Based Task-Oriented Circuit Training on Physical Functions of Stroke Survivors: A Pilot Study in A State Hospital in Kelantan, Malaysia. Asian Journal of Medicine and Biomedicine. 2021;5(S2):5-14.
Kim S-M, Kang S-H. The Effects of Task-Oriented Circuit Training Using Unstable Surface on Balance, Walking and Balance Confidence in Subacute Stroke Patients. Journal of The Korean Society of Integrative Medicine. 2021;9(4):211-23.
Lima ACd, Christofoletti G. Exercises with action observation contribute to upper limb recovery in chronic stroke patients: a controlled clinical trial. Motriz: Revista de Educação Física. 2020;26.
Llorens R, Fuentes MA, Borrego A, Latorre J, Alcañiz M, Colomer C, et al. Effectiveness of a combined transcranial direct current stimulation and virtual reality-based intervention on upper limb function in chronic individuals post-stroke with persistent severe hemiparesis: A randomized controlled trial. Journal of neuroengineering and rehabilitation. 2021;18:1-13.
Lotter JK, Henderson CE, Plawecki A, Holthus ME, Lucas EH, Ardestani MM, et al. Task-specific versus impairment-based training on locomotor performance in individuals with chronic spinal cord injury: a randomized crossover study. Neurorehabilitation and neural repair. 2020;34(7):627-39.
Martins JC, Nadeau S, Aguiar LT, Scianni AA, Teixeira-Salmela LF, De Morais Faria CDC. Efficacy of task-specific circuit training on physical activity levels and mobility of stroke patients: A randomized controlled trial. NeuroRehabilitation. 2020;47(4):451-62.
Mattos DJ, Rutlin J, Hong X, Zinn K, Shimony JS, Carter AR. White matter integrity of contralesional and transcallosal tracts may predict response to upper limb task-specific training in chronic stroke. NeuroImage: Clinical. 2021;31:102710.
Mawase F, Cherry-Allen K, Xu J, Anaya M, Uehara S, Celnik P. Pushing the rehabilitation boundaries: hand motor impairment can be reduced in chronic stroke. Neurorehabilitation and neural repair. 2020;34(8):733-45.
McDonell I, Barr C, van den Berg M. Implementing circuit class training can increase therapy time and functional independence in people with stroke receiving inpatient rehabilitation: findings from a retrospective observational clinical audit. Physiotherapy Theory and Practice. 2023:1-7.
Mooney RA, Cirillo J, Stinear CM, Byblow WD. Neurophysiology of motor skill learning in chronic stroke. Clinical Neurophysiology. 2020;131(4):791-8.
Nath D, Singh N, Saini M, Banduni O, Kumar N, Srivastava MP, et al. Clinical potential and neuroplastic effect of targeted virtual reality based intervention for distal upper limb in post-stroke rehabilitation: a pilot observational study. Disability and Rehabilitation. 2023:1-10.
Palimeris S. Combining a Tailored Strength Training Program with Transcranial Direct-Current Stimulation (tDcs) to Improve Upper Extremity Function in Chronic Stroke Patients: McGill University (Canada); 2020.
Roos MA, Thielman GT, Packel L, Moelter ST, Khakhina S, Klase ZA. The Impact of a Functional Circuit Training Program in People with ChronicStroke: A Non-Randomized Feasibility Study. 2021.
Zaman T, Mukhtar T, Waseem Zaman M, Shahid MN, Bibi S, Fatima A. Effects of task-oriented training on dexterous movements of hands in post stroke patients. International Journal of Neuroscience. 2024;134(2):175-83.