Comparison of the Effects of Stretching and Splinting in Improving the Range of Motion and Functional Status for Prevention of Post-Burn Axillary Contracture

Main Article Content

Raheel Munawar
Sumbul Salik
Sania Maqbool
Rizwan Haider
Tehreem Tariq
Arslan Saeed
Tahmina Kanwal
Muhammad Noman Khar
Laila Niaz Khan

Abstract

Background: Burn injuries often lead to severe complications, including axillary contractures, which can significantly restrict shoulder movement and impact quality of life. The rehabilitation strategies for managing post-burn axillary contractures, particularly stretching and splinting, have been the subject of much research, given their potential to improve shoulder range of motion and functional status.


Objective: This study aims to compare the effects of stretching combined with splinting versus splinting alone on the range of motion and functional status in patients with post-burn axillary contracture, to determine the most effective treatment modality for preventing the development of contractures.


Methods: A single-blinded randomized clinical trial was conducted at the Burn and Plastic Surgery Department of Mayo Hospital, Lahore, over six months. Forty patients aged 20-50 years with Type 1 to Type 3 axillary contractures and shoulder abduction ranging from 20 to 100 degrees were enrolled. Participants were randomly assigned to either Group A (stretching plus splinting) or Group B (splinting alone). Outcomes were measured using the Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) questionnaire and goniometry for shoulder motion range, before and after the interventions. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 25, with paired and independent T-tests applied for within and between-group comparisons, respectively.


Results: The stretching group demonstrated significant improvements in shoulder motion ranges: flexion (91.00 ± 19.97 to 98.75 ± 19.75, p<0.000), extension (34.50 ± 12.13 to 41.85 ± 12.70, p<0.000), abduction (94.50 ± 26.84 to 103.50 ± 25.97, p<0.000), external rotation (34.15 ± 18.79 to 42.85 ± 18.87, p<0.000), and internal rotation (33.95 ± 11.05 to 42.90 ± 11.03, p<0.000). The DASH scores improved from 21.35 ± 3.58 to 31.30 ± 3.48 (p<0.000). Similar improvements were noted in the splinting group but were more pronounced in the stretching group. Between-group analysis revealed significant differences in favor of the stretching group for all measures of shoulder motion and DASH scores.


Conclusion: The study concluded that stretching, when combined with splinting, is more effective than splinting alone in improving shoulder range of motion and functional status in patients with post-burn axillary contracture. These findings suggest that incorporating stretching into the rehabilitation protocols for burn survivors could significantly enhance recovery outcomes.

Article Details

How to Cite
Munawar, R., Salik, S., Maqbool, S., Haider, R., Tariq , T., Saeed, A., Kanwal, T., Khar, M. N., & Khan, L. N. (2024). Comparison of the Effects of Stretching and Splinting in Improving the Range of Motion and Functional Status for Prevention of Post-Burn Axillary Contracture. Journal of Health and Rehabilitation Research, 4(1), 519–524. https://doi.org/10.61919/jhrr.v4i1.422
Section
Articles
Author Biographies

Raheel Munawar, JOHAR PAIN RELIEF CENTER Lahore Pakistan.

Clinical Physiotherapist.

Sumbul Salik, DHQ Hospital Okara Pakistan.

Clinical Physiotherapist, Department of Physical Therapy.

Sania Maqbool, Lahore College for Women University Lahore Pakistan.

Lecturer.

Rizwan Haider, Mayo Hospital Lahore Pakistan.

Physiotherapist.

Tehreem Tariq , International Osteopathic Clinic Lahore Pakistan.

Physical Therapist.

Arslan Saeed, Johar Institute of Professional Studies Lahore Pakistan.

Senior Lecturer.

Tahmina Kanwal, King Edward Medical University Lahore Pakistan.

Physiotherapist.

Muhammad Noman Khar, KAMYAB INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES KOT Addu Pakistan.

Principal, Allied Health Sciences.

Laila Niaz Khan, Johar Institute of Professional Studies Lahore Pakistan.

Lecturer.

References

Jeschke MG, van Baar ME, Choudhry MA, Chung KK, Gibran NS, Logsetty SJNRDP. Burn injury. 2020;6(1):11.

Oosterwijk AM, Mouton LJ, Schouten H, Disseldorp LM, van der Schans CP, Nieuwenhuis MKJB. Prevalence of scar contractures after burn: a systematic review. 2017;43(1):41-9.

Goverman J, Mathews K, Goldstein R, Holavanahalli R, Kowalske K, Esselman P, et al. Adult contractures in burn injury: a burn model system national database study. 2017;38(1):e328-e36.

Holavanahalli RK, Helm PA, Kowalske KJ, Hynan LSJAopm, rehabilitation. Effectiveness of paraffin and sustained stretch in treatment of shoulder contractures following a burn injury. 2020;101(1):S42-S9.

Gorka R, Gupta AK, Prakash S, Bakthavachel I, Lamba S, Gohil AJJBO. Simple, self-adjustable airplane splint for axillary contractures. 2017;1(2):54-8.

Botman M, Hendriks TC, de Haas LE, Mtui GS, Nuwass EQ, Jaspers ME, et al. The effectiveness of burn scar contracture release surgery in low-and middle-income countries. 2020;8(7).

Goel A, Shrivastava PJIjopsopotAoPSoI. Post-burn scars and scar contractures. 2010;43(Suppl):S63.

Tredget EE, Levi B, Donelan MBJSC. Biology and principles of scar management and burn reconstruction. 2014;94(4):793-815.

Ladak A, Tredget EEJCips. Pathophysiology and management of the burn scar. 2009;36(4):661-74.

Goverman J, Mathews K, Goldstein R, Holavanahalli R, Kowalske K, Esselman P, et al. Pediatric contractures in burn injury: a burn model system national database study. 2017;38(1):e192-e9.

Ndiaye L, Sankale A, Ndiaye A, Foba M, Coulibaly NJBO. Management of axillary burn contracture: A summary of 67 cases. 2018;2(3):109-13.

Karki D, Narayan RPJWJoPS. Role of square flap in post burn axillary contractures. 2017;6(3):285.

Kumaran S, Nambi G, Beck B, Paul MK, Gupta AK, Dhanraj PJOpotNAoB-I. A clinical study of post burn contracture of axilla & its management. 2008.

Perera AD, Perera C, Karunanayake A. Effectiveness of early stretching exercises for range of motion in the shoulder joint and quality of functional recovery in patients with burns-a randomized control trial. 2017.

Ashraf U, Maqbool S, Fatima T, Asghar HMU, Anwar M, Baig FJPJoM, et al. Comparison of the effect of Range of Motion exercises versus stretching techniques in prevention of burn contractures of upper limb; RCT-A Randomized clinical trial. 2022;16(05):54-.

Thomas R, Wicks S, Toose C, Pacey VJJoBC, Research. Outcomes of early use of an end of range axilla orthotic in children following burn injury. 2019;40(5):678-88.

Greiser C, Lorello D, Lyons D, Richey KJ, Murray D, Foster KNJJoBC, et al. 639 Maximizing Safe Positioning of Upper Extremities after Axillary Burn Injuries to Prevent Contractures and Maintain Function. 2021;42(Supplement_1):S175-S6.

Karki D, Mehta N, Narayan RPJIJoPS. Post-burn axillary contracture: A therapeutic challenge! 2014;47(03):375-80.

Riaz HM, Cheema SAJIJoB, Trauma. Paraffin wax bath therapy versus therapeutic ultrasound in management of post burn contractures of small joints of hand. 2021;11(3):245.

Ahuja RB, Chatterjee PJIJoB. Management of postburn axillary contractures. 2019;27(1):8.

Aghajanzade M, Momeni M, Niazi M, Ghorbani H, Saberi M, Kheirkhah R, et al. Effectiveness of incorporating occupational therapy in rehabilitation of hand burn patients. 2019;32(2):147.

Phadke A, Bedekar N, Shyam A, Sancheti PJHKPJ. Effect of muscle energy technique and static stretching on pain and functional disability in patients with mechanical neck pain: A randomized controlled trial. 2016;35:5-11.

Tehreem Z, Kazmi Y, Khalid MU, Mansha H, Hassan M, Majeed RJJoUM, et al. Comparison of soft tissue mobilization versus static stretching in post-burn contractures at elbow and wrist, A pilot study. 2022;13(3):408-11.

Wang L, Cui J-B, Xie H-M, Zuo X-Q, He J-L, Jia Z-S, et al. Effects of Different Static Progressive Stretching Durations on Range of Motion, Myofibroblasts, and Collagen in a Posttraumatic Knee Contracture Rat Model. 2022;102(5):pzab300.

Zhang Y-t, Li-Tsang CW, Au RKJHKJoOT. A systematic review on the effect of mechanical stretch on hypertrophic scars after burn injuries. 2017;29(1):1-9.

Tokuyama E, Nagai Y, Takahashi K, Kimata Y, Naruse KJPo. Mechanical stretch on human skin equivalents increases the epidermal thickness and develops the basement membrane. 2015;10(11):e0141989.